Category Archives: Physical Exercise

The things we already know–but don’t often do

Posted by on July 15, 2013 Comments Off on The things we already know–but don’t often do

There is the old Middle Eastern story of the one who journeyed East in search of wisdom. He came upon a stone where he read, “Turn me over.”
He picked up the stone and read on the underside: Why do you seek new knowledge when you do not use that which you already have?

A recently reported Swedish study that followed 71,000 individuals over a 13-year period found that consuming less than five daily servings of fruits and vegetables was associated with higher mortality and shorter survival periods. Those eating one serving of fruit daily lived 19 months longer on average, while those eating 3 servings of vegetables lived 32 months longer.

Now by itself, this is not very surprising. We know that heavy meat consumption is linked to colorectal cancer, particularly in combination with genetic mutations, as described in a recent issue of Smithsonian Magazine. So, the possibility that a different diet would be protective, even by contrast, makes some sense.

Fornaciari subsequently analyzed bone collagen of King Ferrante and other Aragonese nobles, revealing a diet extremely reliant on red meat; this finding may correlate with Ferrante’s cancer. Red meat is widely recognized as an agent that increases risk for mutation of the K-ras gene and subsequent colorectal cancer. (As an example of Ferrante’s carnivorous preferences, a wedding banquet held at his court in 1487 featured, among 15 courses, beef and veal heads covered in their skins, roast ram in a sour cherry broth, roast piglet in vinegar broth and a range of salami, hams, livers, giblets and offal.)

In a similar vein, one out of three Americans suffers from hypertension (high blood pressure), a major risk factor for serious cardiovascular events such as stroke and heart attack. A recent study in JAMA showed that 18 months after the beginning of a study in which the experimental group did home blood pressure monitoring along with pharmacist case management, 71.8 percent had controlled blood pressure compared to the control group with usual care at 57.1 percent.

It would be easier if we had pills that would lower our body weight or a vaccination against high blood pressure. We don’t. But we have knowledge that we are not using: walk more, eat less processed foods and more whole grains, vegetables, and fruits, monitor blood pressure and pulse regularly. No, it is not magic–just the best that we can do.

Two things that might help

Posted by on July 8, 2013 Comments Off on Two things that might help

Two recent studies have yielded two tips that might help make your weight loss program work. They are not magic nor pharmaceutical. I confess that they confirm my own biases and experience, which does not make the findings any more valid.

The first study, which appears in the June 26, 2013 American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (AJCN), is a survey of eleven studies on water consumption and weight reduction.

This review found that increased water consumption was associated with greater weight loss. The reviewers conjectured that either the water satisfied hunger cravings, or that the water substituted non-caloric fluid intake for equivalents that might contribute 400-500 calories per day.

The second study, published online June 3, 2013 in the International Journal of Obesity showed a decreased appetite for food following strenuous exercise. The findings from this study are more limited and guarded: it only studied 17 individuals, and ran counter to other studies that showed no relationship.

We need to hope that something will work to help us reverse the trend toward greater obesity. A Rand study by Sturm and Hattori, published online in September 2012 by the International Journal on Obesity showed the accelerated trend toward obesity in the United States beginning in 1987.

Obesity Change 1987-2010

For example, there is a 13-fold increase of BMI > 50 shown by 1200 on the index above.

While the trend in the following table slowed slightly after 2005, there was still an increase of 70 percent increase in those with BMI > 40 so that 15.5 million Americans or 6.6 percent exceeded that BMI.
Obesity 2000_2010

Something has to give–and it better not be more waistlines.

Illusion and Health

Posted by on June 24, 2013 Comments Off on Illusion and Health

A recent University of Texas study about the gap between perception of adequate exercise and optimal diet and the reality of an individual’s regime sent me googling.

I remembered a similar meme about body image. My memory was that men do not see how fat they are, and women imagine themselves fat when they are not, leading to anorexia.

Here are a few of them, and there are no doubt more:

Those studies raised an important question: how do reality and perception diverge when it comes to health?

So, let’s look at the University of Texas study from the Journal of Women’s Health, entitled Lifestyle and Cancer Prevention in Women: Knowledge, Perceptions, and Compliance with Recommended Guidelines.

Among those who believed that good diet and physical activity prevented cancer, the study found discrepancies (I have color-coded them) between what they believed they were doing and were actually doing as shown in the following table:

Women's Perceptions JWH 20130610

It can be seen that while 85 percent believe they are consuming a healthy diet, only 8.5 percent are eating an adequate amount of fruits and vegetables. While 73.1 percent reported engaging in physical activity to prevent cancer, only 31.5 percent were active enough to have a positive impact.

The study found that the significant predictors of the discrepancy were education, and to a lesser extent race-ethnicity independent of education. While the authors speculate about the reasons for those findings, they are clear and unambiguous about the implications, which I quote at length with the footnotes removed:

This finding has important public health implications. The first implication is that women in the current study reported understanding that engaging in regular physical activity and eating a healthy diet are important behaviors for cancer prevention. Thus, media campaigns and targeted public health messages should focus on the importance of specific frequencies and durations of recommended behaviors (i.e., 5 a Day for Better Health), and place less emphasis on the general importance of health behaviors. This may help attenuate the “underdosing” observed in the current study. Current public health efforts are focusing on making community-wide changes to reduce obesity and improve health.19 These efforts may be enhanced by promoting awareness of potential discrepancies between perceptions of behavior and actual behavior and by highlighting practical ways to integrate specific cancer prevention behaviors into daily life at adequate levels. Furthermore, they should consider the imbalance between educational resources for healthy eating and physical activity and barriers to these behaviors (i.e., society encourages the overconsumption of unhealthy food; low access to fresh produce and places to exercise safely sometimes exists). Given that women often serve as “gatekeepers” of health behavior within their families, efforts to address these discrepancies among women may ultimately have a positive downstream effect on men and children. Because dietary habits are often solidified in childhood, the discrepancies observed in this study could potentially set children up for a lifetime of poor health behaviors. These findings add to the body of existing literature indicating that although health-relevant knowledge and attitudes are generally positively associated with the practice health behaviors, the associations are only modest.

Results further indicated that the observed discrepancies for diet and physical activity were significantly more common among women with less education and among members of racial/ethnic minority groups. This is consistent with a large body of research supporting a social gradient in health (i.e., lower socioeconomic position and minority status are associated with poorer health behaviors and poorer health outcomes). One explanation for this is differential exposure to obesogenic environments. That is, individuals with low socioeconomic status and racial/ethnic minorities have less access to healthier foods such as fruits and vegetables due to higher cost and lower access to grocery stores that carry fresh produce. They also have fewer safe places to engage in physical activity. These women may be particularly vulnerable to perceiving that they are engaging in specific diet and physical activity behaviors to help prevent cancer. However, they may lack the opportunity to fully engage in preventive behaviors, thus failing to engage in such behaviors with sufficient frequency and duration to reduce their cancer risk. Such women may need to be specifically targeted for intervention and may benefit from tailored messages and interventions regarding diet and physical activity.

Do we not all know friends and family and clients who believe they are eating well and exercising adequately, but do not understand why their weight keeps rising, with the attendant complications? Our challenge as a society is not only to find ways of addressing the health problems that are undermining our economy and personal functioning that underpin our nation, but to communicate those findings in a way that is unambiguous and specific. The challenge of communicating the findings of a solution to the public health issues may be even more daunting than isolating those causes.